[en] BACKGROUND: Some of the views contrasting the beneficial and toxic effects of antimicrobials upon wound healing remain controversial. OBJECTIVE: To assess the clinical relevance of histological findings following antimicrobial applications on chronic leg ulcers. METHOD: The present study was performed in three parallel groups of 17 patients suffering from at least 2 similar chronic leg ulcers. Clinical planimetric assessments were performed before and after 3 and 6 weeks of treatment using hydrocolloid dressings. In addition, 1 ulcer in each patient received applications of povidone-iodine (PVP-I), silver sulfadiazine or chlorhexidine digluconate. Histological examinations were made at inclusion and after the 6-week therapy. Time to healing was also recorded. RESULTS: At entry in the study, fibroblasts, macrophages, neutrophils and vessels were abundant in the ulcers. In addition, focal necrotizing vasculitis was related to the microbiological load. Compared to the control lesions, both the healing rate and time to healing of the leg ulcers showed a modest improvement at the sites receiving silver sulfadiazine (2-7%) or chlorhexidine digluconate (-1 to 5%). By contrast, PVP-I increased significantly the healing rate (4-18%, p < 0.01), and time to healing was reduced by 2-9 weeks (p < 0.01). The 3 antimicrobials decreased the bacterial density, and the vascular margination and migration of inflammatory cells, thus abating the vasculitic changes. PVP-I applications did not alter the microvessels and did not significantly reduce the density in dendrocytes and fibroblasts. By contrast, both silver sulfadiazine and chorhexidine digluconate appeared to alter the superficial microsvasculature including the dendrocyte population. CONCLUSION: Although topical antimicrobials may apparently achieve almost similar activity on the bacterial load inside chronic leg ulcers, the toxicity upon host cells was different among these agents. PVP-I appeared to be an efficient compound in these respects exhibiting a positive and relevant clinical effect.
Disciplines :
Dermatology
Author, co-author :
Fumal, I.; Centre Hospitalier régional de Huy > Dermatologie
Braham, C.; Centre Hospitalier Régional de Huy > Dermatologie
Paquet, Philippe ; Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Liège - CHU > Dermatopathologie
Pierard, Claudine ; Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Liège - CHU > Dermatopathologie
Pierard, Gérald ; Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Liège - CHU > Dermatopathologie
Language :
English
Title :
The beneficial toxicity paradox of antimicrobials in leg ulcer healing impaired by a polymicrobial flora: a proof-of-concept study.
Lookingbill, D.P., Miller, S.H., Knowles, R.C., Bacteriology of chronic leg ulcers (1978) Arch Dermatol, 114, pp. 1765-1768
Eriksson, G., Eklund, A.E., Kalling, L.O., The clinical significance of bacterial growth in venous leg ulcers (1984) Scand J Infect Dis, 16, pp. 175-180
Robins, P., May, A., Lew, R., A multivariate analysis of factors affecting wound healing time (1984) Dermatol Surg Oncol, 10, pp. 219-221
Annoni, F., Rosian, M., Chiurazzi, D., Ceva, M., The effects of a hydrocolloid dressing on bacterial growth and the healing process of leg ulcers (1989) Int Angiol, 8, pp. 224-228
Gilchrist, B., Reed, C., The bacteriology of chronic venous ulcers treated with occlusive hydrocolloid dressings (1989) Br J Dermatol, 121, pp. 337-344
Robson, M.C., Stenberg, B.D., Heggers, J.P., Wound healing alterations caused by infection (1990) Clin Plast Surg, 17, pp. 485-492
Halbert, A.R., Stacey, M.C., Rohr, J.B., Jopp-McKay, A., The effect of bacterial colonization on venous ulcer healing (1992) Australas J Dermatol, 33, pp. 75-80
Urbani-Rovan, V., Gubina, M., Infection in superficial diabetic foot ulcers (1997) Clin Infect Dis, 25 (SUPPL. 2), pp. 184-185
Brook, I., Frazier, E.H., Aerobic and anaerobic microbiology of chronic venous ulcers (1998) Int J Dermatol, 37, pp. 426-428
Letawe, C., Avila-Camacho, M., Piérard-Franchimont, C., Piérard, G.E., Infection locale et processus de cicatrisation de l'escarre (1998) L'escarre, pp. 94-99. , Colin D, Barrois B, Pelissier J (eds). Paris, Masson
Cooper, M.L., Laxer, J.A., Hansbrough, J.F., The cytotoxic effects of commonly used topical antimicrobial agents on human fibroblasts and keratinocytes (1992) J Trauma, 31, pp. 775-784
Teepe, R.G.C., Koebrugge, E.J., Löwik, C.W.G.M., Petit, P.L.C., Bosboom, R.W., Twiss, I.M., Boxma, H., Ponec, M., Cytotoxic effects of topical antimicrobial and antiseptic agents on human keratinocytes in vitro (1993) J Trauma, 35, pp. 8-19
Kjolseth, D., Frank, J.M., Barker, J.H., Anderson, G.C., Rosenthal, A.I., Acland, R.D., Schuschke, D., Weiner, L.J., Comparison of the effects of commonly used wound agents on epithelialization and neovascularization (1994) J Am Coll Surg, 179, pp. 405-312
Kautzky, F., Hartinger, A., Köhler, L.D., Vogt, H.J., In vitro cytotoxicity of antimicrobial agents to human keratinocytes (1996) J Eur Acad Dermatol, 6, pp. 159-166
Hellewell, T.B., Major, D.A., Foresman, P.A., Rodeheaver, G.T., A cytotoxicity evaluation of antimicrobial and non-antimicrobial wound cleansers (1997) Wounds, 9, pp. 15-20
Niedner, R., Cytotoxicity and sensitization of povidone-iodine and other frequently used anti-infective agents (1997) Dermatology, 195 (SUPPL. 2), pp. 89-92
Niedner, R., Schopf, E., Inhibition of wound healing by antiseptics (1986) Br J Dermatol, 115 (SUPPL. 31), pp. 41-44
Skog, E., Arnesjö, B., Troëng, T., Gjöres, J.E., Bergljung, L., Gundersen, R.J., Hallböök, T., Norgren, L., A randomized trial comparing cadexomer iodine and standard treatment in the out-patient management of chronic venous ulcers (1983) Br J Dermatol, 109, pp. 77-83
Miyachi, Y., Imamura, S., Use of sugar and povidone-iodine in the treatment of refractory cutaneous ulcers (1990) J Dermatol Treat, 1, pp. 191-193
Goldenheim, P.D., An appraisal of povidone-iodine and wound healing (1993) Postgrad Med J, 69 (SUPPL. 3), pp. 97-105
Mayer, D.A., Tsapogas, M.J., Povidone-iodine and wound healing: A critical review (1993) Wounds, 5, pp. 14-23
Piérard-Franchimont, C., Paquet, R., Arrese, J.E., Piérard, G.E., Healing rate and bacterial necrotizing vasculitis in venous leg ulcers (1997) Dermatology, 194, pp. 383-387
Hansson, C., The effects of cadexomer iodine paste in the treatment of venous leg ulcers compared with hydrocolloid dressing and paraffin gauze dressing (1998) Int J Dermatol, 37, pp. 390-396
Hermanns, J.F., Paquet, P., Arrese, J.E., Piérard-Franchimont, Piérard, G.E., La cytotoxicité bénéfique des antiseptiques: Une antinomie paradoxale et controversée du traitement des plaies cutanées chroniques (1999) Rev Méd Liège, 54, pp. 600-605
Reimer, K., Vogt, P.M., Broegmann, B., Hauser, J., Rossbach, O., Kramer, A., Rudolph, P., Fleischer, W., An innovative topical drug formulation for wound healing and infection treatment: In vitro and in vivo investigations of a povidone-iodine liposome hydrogel (2000) Dermatology, 201, pp. 235-241
Burnand, K.G., Whimster, I., Naidoo, A., Browse, N.L., Pericapillary fibrin in the ulcer-bearing skin of the leg: The cause of lipodermatosclerosis and venous ulceration (1982) Br Med J, 285, pp. 1071-1072
Ulrich, J.A., Antimicrobial efficacy in the presence of organic matter (1981) Skin Microbiology: Relevance to Clinical Infections, pp. 149-157. , Maibach H, Aly R (eds). New York, Springer
Van der Broek, P.J., Buys, L.F., Van Furth, R., Interaction of povidone-iodine compounds, phagocytic cells, and microorganisms (1982) Antimicrob Agents Chemother, 22, pp. 593-597
Mertz, P.M., Alvarez, O.M., Smerbeck, R.V., Eaglstein, W.H., A new in vivo model for the evaluation of topical antiseptics on superficial wounds: The effect of 70% alcohol and povidone iodine solution (1984) Arch Dermatol, 120, pp. 58-62
Gottardi, W., The uptake and release of molecular iodine by the skin: Chemical and bactericidal evidence of residual effects caused by povidone-iodine preparations (1995) J Hosp Infect, 29, pp. 9-18
Hansson, C., Faergemann, J., The effect of antiseptic solutions on microorganisms in venous leg ulcers (1995) Acta Dermatol Venereol, 75, pp. 31-33
Traoré, O., Fournet Fayard, S., Laveran, H., An in vitro evaluation in the activity of povidone-iodine against nosocomial bacterial strains (1996) J Hosp Infect, 34, pp. 217-222
Fleischer, W., Reimer, K., Povidone-iodine in antisepsis: State of the art (1997) Dermatology, 195 (SUPPL. 2), pp. 3-9
Kunisada, T., Yamada, K., Oda, S., Hara, O., Investigation of the efficacy of povidone-iodine against antiseptic-resistant species (1997) Dermatology, 195 (SUPPL. 2), pp. 14-18
Deleixhe-Mauhin, F., Piérard, G.E., Piérard-Franchimont, C., Cornil, F., Goffin, F., A morphomet-ric analysis of the healing rate of ulcerations on atrophie blanche during simple nursing care (1991) Eur J Dermatol, 1, pp. 101-104
Piérard, G.E., Piérard-Franchimont, C., Planimetry of the healing rate of leg ulcers (1995) Eur J Dermatol, 5, pp. 257-262
Scott, H.J., McMullin, G.M., Coleridge Smith, P.D., Scurr, J.H., A histological study of white blood cells and their association with lipodermatosclerosis and ulceration (1991) Br J Surg, 78, pp. 210-211
Rosner, K., Ross, C., Karlsmark, T., Petersen, A.A., Gottrup, F., Vejlsgaard, G.L., Immunohistochem-ical characterization of the cutaneous cellular infiltrate in different areas of chronic leg ulcers (1995) Acta Pathol Microbiol Immunol Scand, 103, pp. 293-299
Moore, K., Thomas, A., Harding, K.G., Iodine released from the wound dressing Iodosorb modulates the secretion of cytokines by human macrophages responding to bacterial lipopolysaccharide (1997) Int J Biochem Cell Biol, 29, pp. 163-171
Wallace, H.J., Stacey, M.C., Levels of tumour necrosis factor-α(TNF-α) and soluble TNF receptor in chronic venous leg ulcers: Correlations to healing status (1998) J Invest Dermatol, 110, pp. 292-296
Piérard, G.E., Arrese Estrada, J., Piérard-Franchimont, C., Deleixhe-Mauhin, F., Is there a link between dendrocytes, fibrosis and sclerosis? (1990) Dermatologica, 181, pp. 264-265
Vanscheidt, W., Hasler, K., Wokalek, H., Niedner, R., Schöpf, E., Factor XIII deficiency in the blood of venous leg ulcer patients (1991) Acta Derm Venereol, 71, pp. 55-57
Herouy, Y., Nockowski, P., Schopf, E., Norgauer, J., Lipodermatosclerosis and the significance of proteolytic remodeling in the pathogenesis of venous ulceration (1999) Int J Mol Med, 3, pp. 511-515
Ravanti, L., Kahari, V., Matrix metalloproteinases in wound repair (2000) Int J Mol Med, 6, pp. 391-407
