[en] Indexing glomerular filtration rate (GFR) for body surface area (BSA) is often realized without arising any questions. However, physiological basis for such an indexation are very poor. Indeed, indexing GFR for BSA to avoid variation due to differences in body size necessarily implies that GFR is a linear function of BSA and that the intercept of this linear function is zero. Moreover, when GFR is indexed for BSA, the relation indexed GFR-BSA must completely disappear. These physiological prerequisites are not found for BSA indexation. We will review the history of this indexation and will underline errors and defaults. Different equations to estimate BSA exist and will be discussed. The choice of "1.73m(2)" will be also criticized. Moreover, indexing GFR for BSA has little impact on GFR results in "normal" body size population. Nevertheless, this indexation will have strong consequences in very lean (such as anorexia) and in obese patients. We will discuss possible alternatives proposed to substitute for BSA indexation.
Disciplines :
Urology & nephrology
Author, co-author :
Delanaye, Pierre ; Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Liège - CHU > Néphrologie
Mariat, Christophe
Cavalier, Etienne ; Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Liège - CHU > Chimie médicale
Delanaye P., Radermecker R.P., Rorive M., Depas G., and Krzesinski J.M. Indexing glomerular filtration rate for body surface area in obese patients is misleading: concept and example. Nephrol Dial Transplant 20 (2005) 2024-2028
Mathew T.H. Chronic kidney disease and automatic reporting of estimated glomerular filtration rate: a position statement. Med J Aust 183 (2005) 138-141
Lamb E.J., Tomson C.R., and Roderick P.J. Estimating kidney function in adults using formulae. Ann Clin Biochem 42 (2005) 321-345
Krovetz L.J. The physiologic significance of body surface area. J Pediatr 67 (1965) 841-862
Tanner J.M. Fallacy of per-weight and per-surface area standards, and their relation to spurious correlation. J Appl Physiol 2 (1949) 1-15
Turner S.T., and Reilly S.L. Fallacy of indexing renal and systemic hemodynamic measurements for body surface area. Am J Physiol 268 (1995) R978-R988
Rubin M.I., Bruck E., and Rapoport M. Maturation of renal function in childhood; clearance studies. J Clin Invest 28 (1949) 1144-1162
White A.J., and Strydom W.J. Normalisation of glomerular filtration rate measurements. Eur J Nucl Med 18 (1991) 385-390
Kronmal R.A. Spurious correlation and the fallacy of the ratio standard revisited. J R Statist Soc A 156 (1993) 379-392
McIntosh J.F., Möller R., and Van Slycke D.D. Studies on urea excretions. III. The influence of body size on urea output. J Clin Invest 6 (1928) 467-483
Holten C. The dependence of the normal kidney function on the size of the body. Acta Paediatr Stock 12 (1931) 251-267
Taylor F.B., Drury D.R., and Addis T. The regulation of renal activity. The relation between the rate of urea excretion and the size of the kidneys. Am J Physiol 65 (1923) 55-61
Stewart G.N. Possible relations of the weight of the lungs and other organs to body-weight and surface area (in dogs). Am J Physiol 58 (1921) 45-52
MacKay E.M. Kidney weight, body size and renal function. Arch Intern Med 50 (1932) 590-594
Albrecht G.H., Gelvin B.R., and Hartman S.E. Ratios as a size adjustment in morphometrics. Am J Phys Anthropol 91 (1993) 441-468
Watson W.S. Body surface area correction in single-sample methods of glomerular filtration rate estimation. Nucl Med Commun 21 (2000) 121-122
Dooley M.J., and Poole S.G. Poor correlation between body surface area and glomerular filtration rate. Cancer Chemother Pharmacol 46 (2000) 523-526
Morgan D.B., Dillon S., and Payne R.B. The assessment of glomerular function: creatinine clearance or plasma creatinine?. Postgrad Med J 54 (1978) 302-310
Nyengaard J.R., and Bendtsen T.F. Glomerular number and size in relation to age, kidney weight, and body surface in normal man. Anat Rec 232 (1992) 194-201
Smith H. The kidney: Structure and function in health and disease (1951), Oxford University Press, New York
Bird N.J., Henderson B.L., Lui D., Ballinger J.R., and Peters A.M. Indexing glomerular filtration rate to suit children. J Nucl Med 44 (2003) 1037-1043
Flegal K.M. Epidemiologic aspects of overweight and obesity in the United States. Physiol Behav 86 (2005) 599-602
Lee J.Y., and Choi J.W. Validity and reliability of an alginate method to measure body surface area. J Physiol Anthropol 25 (2006) 247-255
Verbraecken J., Van de H.P., De Backer W., and Van Gaal L. Body surface area in normal-weight, overweight, and obese adults. A comparison study. Metabolism 55 (2006) 515-524
Kaestner S.A., and Sewell G.J. Chemotherapy dosing part I: scientific basis for current practice and use of body surface area. Clin Oncol (R Coll Radiol) 19 (2007) 23-37
Felici A., Verweij J., and Sparreboom A. Dosing strategies for anticancer drugs: the good, the bad and body-surface area. Eur J Cancer 38 (2002) 1677-1684
Grochow L.B., Baraldi C., and Noe D. Is dose normalization to weight or body surface area useful in adults?. J Natl Cancer Inst 82 (1990) 323-325
van der Sijs H., and Guchelaar H.J. Formulas for calculating body surface area. Ann Pharmacother 36 (2002) 345-346
Hunter R.J., Navo M.A., Thaker P.H., Bodurka D.C., Wolf J.K., and Smith J.A. Dosing chemotherapy in obese patients: Actual versus assigned body surface area (BSA). Cancer Treat Rev (2008)
Fisk E.L., and Crawford J.R. How to make the periodic health examination (1927), Macmillan, New York 345
Heaf J.G. The origin of the 1 × 73-m2 body surface area normalization: problems and implications. Clin Physiol Funct Imaging 27 (2007) 135-137
Health Satistics. Key data on health. 2002; 146. Luxembourg, Office for official publications of the European Community.
Ogden C.L., Fryar C.D., Carroll M.D., and Flegal K.M. Mean body weight, height, and body mass index, United States 1960-2002. Adv Data (2004) 1-17
Sendroy Jr. J., and Cecchini L.P. Determination of human body surface area from height and weight. J Appl Physiol 7 (1954) 1-12
Gehan E.A., and George S.L. Estimation of human body surface area from height and weight. Cancer Chemother Rep 54 (1970) 225-235
Bailey B.J., and Briars G.L. Estimating the surface area of the human body. Stat Med 15 (1996) 1325-1332
Lee J.Y., Choi J.W., and Kim H. Determination of body surface area and formulas to estimate body surface area using the alginate method. J Physiol Anthropol 27 (2008) 71-82
Slone T.H. Body surface area misconceptions. Risk Anal 13 (1993) 375-377
Gibson S., and Numa A. The importance of metabolic rate and the folly of body surface area calculations. Anaesthesia 58 (2003) 50-55
Dubois D., and DuBois E.F. The measurement of the surface area of man. Arch Intern Med 16 (1915) 868-881
Rubner M. Ueber den einfluss der körpergrösse auf stoff- und draftwechsel. Z Biol 19 (1883) 535-562
Meeh K. Oberflächenmessungen des menschlichen Körpers. Zeitschrift Fur Biologie 15 (1879) 425-458
Dubois D., and Dubois E. A formula to estimate the approximative surface area if height and weight be known. Arch Intern Med 17 (1916) 863-871
Sawyer M., Stone R.H., and Du Bois E.F. Further measurements of the surface area of adults and children. Arch Intern Med 17 (1916) 855-862
Livingston E.H., and Lee S. Body surface area prediction in normal-weight and obese patients. Am J Physiol Endocrinol Metab 281 (2001) E586-E591
Shuter B., and Aslani A. Body surface area: Du Bois and Du Bois revisited. Eur J Appl Physiol 82 (2000) 250-254
Reading B.D., and Freeman B. Simple formula for the surface area of the body and a simple model for anthropometry. Clin Anat 18 (2005) 126-130
Blake G.M., and Grewal G.S. An evaluation of the body surface area correction for 51Cr-EDTA measurements of glomerular filtration rate. Nucl Med Commun 26 (2005) 447-451
Burton R.F. Estimating body surface area from mass and height: theory and the formula of Du Bois and Du Bois. Ann Hum Biol 35 (2008) 170-184
Mosteller R.D. Simplified calculation of body-surface area. N Engl J Med 317 (1987) 1098
Haycock G.B., Schwartz G.J., and Wisotsky D.H. Geometric method for measuring body surface area: a height-weight formula validated in infants, children, and adults. J Pediatr 93 (1978) 62-66
Tucker G.R., and Alexander J.K. Estimation of body surface area of extremely obese human subjects. J Appl Physiol 15 (1960) 781-784
Tikuisis P., Meunier P., and Jubenville C.E. Human body surface area: measurement and prediction using three dimensional body scans. Eur J Appl Physiol 85 (2001) 264-271
Schmieder R.E., Beil A.H., Weihprecht H., and Messerli F.H. How should renal hemodynamic data be indexed in obesity?. J Am Soc Nephrol 5 (1995) 1709-1713
Anastasio P., Spitali L., Frangiosa A., Molino D., Stellato D., Cirillo E., et al. Glomerular filtration rate in severely overweight normotensive humans. Am J Kidney Dis 35 (2000) 1144-1148
Hallynck T.H., Soep H.H., Thomis J.A., Boelaert J., Daneels R., and Dettli L. Should clearance be normalised to body surface or to lean body mass?. Br J Clin Pharmacol 11 (1981) 523-526
Kurtin P.S. Standardization of renal function measurements in children: kidney size versus metabolic rate. Child Nephrol Urol 9 (1988) 337-339
Walser M. Progression of chronic renal failure in man. Kidney Int 37 (1990) 1195-1210
McCance R.A., and Widdowson E.M. The correct physiological basis on which to compare infant and adult renal function. Lancet 2 (1952) 860-862
Peters A.M. Expressing glomerular filtration rate in terms of extracellular fluid volume. Nephrol Dial Transplant 7 (1992) 205-210
Peters A.M., Gordon I., and Sixt R. Normalization of glomerular filtration rate in children: body surface area, body weight or extracellular fluid volume?. J Nucl Med 35 (1994) 438-444
Piepsz A., Tondeur M., and Ham H. Escaping the correction for body surface area when calculating glomerular filtration rate in children. Eur J Nucl Med Mol Imaging 35 (2008) 1669-1672
Visser F.W., Muntinga J.H., Dierckx R.A., and Navis G. Feasibility and impact of the measurement of extracellular fluid volume simultaneous with GFR by 125I-iothalamate. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol 3 (2008) 1308-1315
Bird N.J., Peters C., Michell A.R., and Peters A.M. Reproducibilities and responses to food intake of GFR measured with chromium-51-EDTA and iohexol simultaneously and independently in normal subjects. Nephrol Dial Transplant 23 (2008) 1902-1909
Delanaye P., Cavalier E., Froissart M., and Krzesinski J.M. Reproducibility of GFR measured by chromium-51-EDTA and iohexol. Nephrol Dial Transplant 23 (2008) 4077-4078
Neilan T.G., Pradhan A.D., and Weyman A.E. Derivation of a size-independent variable for scaling of cardiac dimensions in a normal adult population. J Am Soc Echocardiogr 21 (2008) 779-785
Neilan T.G., Pradhan A.D., King M.E., and Weyman A.E. Derivation of a size-independent variable for scaling of cardiac dimensions in a normal paediatric population. Eur J Echocardiogr 10 (2008) 50-55
Ribstein J., du C.G., and Mimran A. Combined renal effects of overweight and hypertension. Hypertension 26 (1995) 610-615
Macdonald J., Marcora S., Jibani M., Roberts G., Kumwenda M., Glover R., et al. GFR estimation using cystatin C is not independent of body composition. Am J Kidney Dis 48 (2006) 712-719
Chagnac A., Weinstein T., Korzets A., Ramadan E., Hirsch J., and Gafter U. Glomerular hemodynamics in severe obesity. Am J Physiol Renal Physiol 278 (2000) F817-F822
Chagnac A., Weinstein T., Herman M., Hirsh J., Gafter U., and Ori Y. The effects of weight loss on renal function in patients with severe obesity. J Am Soc Nephrol 14 (2003) 1480-1486
Henegar J.R., Bigler S.A., Henegar L.K., Tyagi S.C., and Hall J.E. Functional and structural changes in the kidney in the early stages of obesity. J Am Soc Nephrol 12 (2001) 1211-1217
Bosma R.J., van der Heide J.J., Oosterop E.J., de Jong P.E., and Navis G. Body mass index is associated with altered renal hemodynamics in non-obese healthy subjects. Kidney Int 65 (2004) 259-265
Navarro-Diaz M., Serra A., Romero R., Bonet J., Bayes B., Homs M., et al. Effect of drastic weight loss after bariatric surgery on renal parameters in extremely obese patients: long-term follow-up. J Am Soc Nephrol 17 (2006) S213-S217
Boyd E. The growth of the Surface of the Human Body (1935), University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis
Piepsz A., Tondeur M., and Ham H. Escaping the correction for body surface area when calculating glomerular filtration rate in children. Eur J Nucl Med Mol Imaging (2008)
