hydro-economic model; cost-effectiveness analysis; cost-benefit analysis; groundwater,; agri-environmental schemes; European Water Framework Directive
Abstract :
[en] In Europe, 30% of groundwater bodies are considered to be at risk of not achieving the
Water Framework Directive (WFD) ‘good status’ objective by 2015, and 45% are in doubt of
doing so. Diffuse agricultural pollution is one of the main pressures affecting groundwater
bodies. To tackle this problem, the WFD requires Member States to design and implement
cost-effective programs of measures to achieve the ‘good status’ objective by 2027 at the
latest. Hitherto, action plans have mainly consisted of promoting the adoption of Agri-
Environmental Schemes (AES). This raises a number of questions concerning the
effectiveness of such schemes for improving groundwater status, and the economic
implications of their implementation. We propose a hydro-economic model that combines a
hydrogeological model to simulate groundwater quality evolution with agronomic and
economic components to assess the expected costs, effectiveness, and benefits of AES
implementation. This hydro-economic model can be used to identify cost-effective AES
combinations at groundwater-body scale and to show the benefits to be expected from the
resulting improvement in groundwater quality. The model is applied here to a rural area
encompassing the Hesbaye aquifer, a large chalk aquifer which supplies about 230,000
inhabitants in the city of Liege (Belgium) and is severely contaminated by agricultural
nitrates. We show that the time frame within which improvements in the Hesbaye
groundwater quality can be expected may be much longer than that required by the WFD.
Current WFD programs based on AES may be inappropriate for achieving the ‘good status’
objective in the most productive agricultural areas, in particular because these schemes are
insufficiently attractive. Achieving ‘good status’ by 2027 would demand a substantial change
in the design of AES, involving costs that may not be offset by benefits in the case of chalk
aquifers with long renewal times.
Hérivaux, Cécile; Bureau de Recherches Géologiques et Minières - BRGM > Direction Eau, Environnement et Ecotechnologies > Unité Nouvelles Ressources et Economie
Orban, Philippe ; Université de Liège - ULiège > Département Argenco : Secteur GEO3 > Hydrogéologie & Géologie de l'environnement
Brouyère, Serge ; Université de Liège - ULiège > Département Argenco : Secteur GEO3 > Hydrogéologie & Géologie de l'environnement
Language :
English
Title :
Is it worth protecting groundwater from diffuse pollution with agri-environmental schemes? A hydro-economic modeling approach
Publication date :
2013
Journal title :
Journal of Environmental Management
ISSN :
0301-4797
eISSN :
1095-8630
Publisher :
Academic Press, London, United Kingdom
Volume :
128
Pages :
62-74
Peer reviewed :
Peer Reviewed verified by ORBi
Name of the research project :
FP6 IP AquaTerra
Funders :
DG RDT - Commission Européenne. Direction Générale de la Recherche et de l'Innovation [BE]
Abdalla C.W. Groundwater values from avoidance cost studies: implications for policy and future research. Am. J. Agric. Econ. 1994, 76:1062-1067.
AERM Méthodes et procédures pour l'état des lieux des districts Rhin et Meuse - Sambre. Document de référence. Version finale approuvée par le comité de bassin du 4 février 2005 et approuvée par le préfet coordonateur de bassin. Etat des lieux des districts Rhin et Meuse - partie française 2005.
Almasri M.N., Kaluarachchi J.J. Multi-criteria decision analysis for the optimal management of nitrate contamination of aquifers. J.Environ. Manage. 2005, 74:365-381. 10.1016/j.jenvman.2004.10.006.
Aquawal Etude quantitative et qualitative de l'usage des systèmes d'adoucissement de l'eau distribuée en Région Wallonne. Partie 1: Cadastre des adoucisseurs d'eau domestiques 2005, Rapport final.
Batlle Aguilar J., Orban P., Dassargues A., Brouyère S. Identification of groundwater quality trends in a chalk aquifer threatened by intensive agriculture in Belgium. Hydrogeology J. 2007, 15:1615-1627. 10.1007/s10040-007-0204-y.
Baumol W.J., Oates W.E. The Theory of Environmental Policy 1988, Cambridge University Press.
Baylis K., Peplow S., Rausser G., Simon L. Agri-environmental policies in the EU and United States: a comparison. Ecol. Econ. 2008, 65:753-764. 10.1016/j.ecolecon.2007.07.034.
Bouscasse H., Defrance P., Strosser P. Evaluation des bénéfices attendus de l'amélioration de l'état des eaux souterraines en Région wallonne 2009, Rapport final, Acteon/Direction Générale des Ressources Naturelles et de l'Environnement - Région Wallonne.
Brouwer R., Hofkes M. Integrated hydro-economic modelling: approaches, key issues and future research directions. Ecol. Econ. 2008, 66:16-22. 10.1016/j.ecolecon.2008.02.009.
Brouyère S. Etude et modélisation du transport et du piégeage des solutés en milieu souterrain variablement saturé 2001, University of Liège, Liège, Belgium, PhD Thesis.
Brouyère S., Carabin G., Dassargues A. Climate change impacts on groundwater resources: modelled deficits in a chalky aquifer, Geer basin, Belgium. Hydrogeology J. 2004, 12:123-134. 10.1007/s10040-003-0293-1.
Brouyère S., Orban P., Wildemeersch S., Couturier J., Gardin N., Dassargues A. The hybrid finite element mixing cell method: a new flexible method for modelling mine ground water problems. Mine Water Environ. 2009, 28:102-114. 10.1007/s10230-009-0069-5.
Carabin G., Dassargues A. Modeling groundwater with ocean and river interaction. Water Resour. Res. 1999, 35.
Claassen R., Cattaneo A., Johansson R. Cost-effective design of agri-environmental payment programs: U.S. experience in theory and practice. Ecol. Econ. 2008, 65:737-752. 10.1016/j.ecolecon.2007.07.032.
Collins A.L., McGonigle D.F. Monitoring and modelling diffuse pollution from agriculture for policy support: UK and European experience. Environ. Sci. Policy 2008, 11:97-101. 10.1016/j.envsci.2008.01.001.
Commissariat Général du Plan Révision du taux d'actualisation des investissements publics 2005, Rapport du groupe d'experts présidé par Daniel Lebègue.
Dautrebande S., Sohier C. Modélisation hydrologique des sols et des pratiques agricoles en Région wallone (sous-bassins de la Meuse et de l'Escaut) 2004, Rapport final du programme intégré de recherche Environnement-Eau (PIRENE).
EC Towards Sustainable Water Management in the European Union. First Stage in the Implementation of the Water Framework Directive 2000/60/EC 2007, Commission staff working document.
Falconer K., Whitby M. The Transaction and Administration Costs of Countryside Stewardship Policies: an Investigation for Eight European Member States 1999, Research Report, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Centre for Rural Economy.
Graveline N., Rinaudo J.D., Segger V., Lambrecht H., Casper M., Elsass P., Grimm-Strele J., Gudera T., Koller R., Van Dijk P. Integrating economic and groundwater models for developing long-term nitrate concentration scenarios in a large aquifer. Aquifer Systems Management: Darcy's Legacy in a World of Impending Water Shortage. Selected Papers on Hydrogeology N. 10. IAH Selected Papers 2007, 483-495.
Graveline N., Rinaudo J. Constructing scenarios of agricultural diffuse pollution using an integrated hydro-economic modelling approach. Eur. Water 2007, 17:18.
Grønvald P., Delfs Mortensen L., Folmand Knudsen C., Bohr R., Brandt G., Bülow D., Seidelin C., Nielsen T., Aue C., Seitz O., Dahlman M., Kooistra A., van der Moot N., van Os B., Lovett A., Hiscock K., Bateman I., Sunnenberg G., Jackson H., Jackson H., Johnson P., Burke S. Watercost, Elements of Cost-effectiveness Analysis, Method and Case Studies 2008, vol. 107.
Haaren C., Bathke M. Integrated landscape planning and remuneration of agri-environmental services: results of a case study in the Fuhrberg region of Germany. J.Environ. Manage. 2008, 89:209-221. 10.1016/j.jenvman.2007.01.058.
Hallet V. Étude de la contamination de la nappe aquifère de Hesbaye par les nitrates: hydrogéologie, hydrochimie et modélisation mathématique des écoulements et du transport en milieu saturé (contamination of the Hesbaye aquifer by nitrates: hydrogeology, hydrochemistry and mathematical modeling) 1998, University of Liège, Faculty of Sciences, French, PhD Thesis.
Hanley N., Whitby M., Simpson I. Assessing the success of agri-environmental policy in the UK. Land Use Policy 1999, 16:67-80. 10.1016/S0264-8377(98)00041-6.
Hasler B., Lundhede T., Martinsen L., Neye S.T., Schou J.S. Economic assessment of the value of drinking water management in Denmark by groundwater protection and purification of polluted groundwater. Discussion Paper for the Seminar on Environmental Services and Financing for the Protection and Sustainable Use of Ecosystems. Geneve, 10-11 October 2005 2005.
Heinz I., Pulido-Velazquez M., Lund J., Andreu J. Hydro-economic modeling in river basin management: implications and applications for the European water framework directive. Water Resour. Manage. 2007, 21:1103-1125. 10.1007/s11269-006-9101-8.
Jackson B.M., Browne C.A., Butler A.P., Peach D., Wade A.J., Wheater H.S. Nitrate transport in chalk catchments: monitoring, modelling and policy implications. Environ. Sci. Policy 2008, 11:125-135. 10.1016/j.envsci.2007.10.006.
Ledoux E., Gomez E., Monget J.M., Viavattene C., Viennot P., Ducharne A., Benoit M., Mignolet C., Schott C., Mary B. Agriculture and groundwater nitrate contamination in the Seine basin. The STICS-MODCOU modelling chain. Sci. Total Environ. 2007, 375:33-47. 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2006.12.002.
Orban P. Solute Transport Modelling at the Groundwater Body Scale: Nitrate Trends Assessment in the Geer Basin (Belgium) 2009, 219. PhD Thesis, University of Liège, Faculty of Applied Sciences, Liège.
Orban P., Brouyère S., Batlle-Aguilar J., Couturier J., Goderniaux P., Leroy M., Maloszewski P., Dassargues A. Regional transport modelling for nitrate trend assessment and forecasting in a chalk aquifer. J.Contam. Hydrol. 2010, 118:79-93. 10.1016/j.jconhyd.2010.08.008.
Peña-Haro S., Llopis-Albert C., Pulido-Velazquez M., Pulido-Velazquez D. Fertilizer standards for controlling groundwater nitrate pollution from agriculture: El Salobral-Los Llanos case study, Spain. J.Hydrol. 2010, 392:174-187. 10.1016/j.jhydrol.2010.08.006.
Peña-Haro S., Pulido-Velazquez M., Sahuquillo A. Ahydro-economic modelling framework for optimal management of groundwater nitrate pollution from agriculture. J.Hydrol. 2009, 373:193-203. 10.1016/j.jhydrol.2009.04.024.
Primdahl J., Peco B., Schramek J., Andersen E., Oñate J.J. Environmental effects of agri-environmental schemes in Western Europe. J.Environ. Manage. 2003, 67:129-138. 10.1016/S0301-4797(02)00192-5.
Primdahl J., Vesterager J.P., Finn J.A., Vlahos G., Kristensen L., Vejre H. Current use of impact models for agri-environment schemes and potential for improvements of policy design and assessment. J.Environ. Manage. 2010, 91:1245-1254. 10.1016/j.jenvman.2009.12.012.
Purvis G., Louwagie G., Northey G., Mortimer S., Park J., Mauchline A., Finn J., Primdahl J., Vejre H., Vesterager J.P., Knickel K., Kasperczyk N., Balázs K., Vlahos G., Christopoulos S., Peltola J. Conceptual development of a harmonised method for tracking change and evaluating policy in the agri-environment: the agri-environmental footprint Index. Environ. Sci. Policy 2009, 12:321-337. 10.1016/j.envsci.2009.01.005.
Ramon S., Benoit M. L'évolution de la nature des cultures en Lorraine et en Alsace: une menace pour les nappes. Courr. Environ. INRA 1998, 33:98-100.
Rinaudo J., Arnal C., Blanchin R., Elsass P., Meilhac A., Loubier S. Assessing the cost of groundwater pollution: the case of diffuse agricultural pollution in the Upper Rhine valley aquifer. Water Sci. Technol. 2005, 52:153-162.
Toma L., Mathijs E. Environmental risk perception, environmental concern and propensity to participate in organic farming programmes. J.Environ. Manage. 2007, 83:145-157. 10.1016/j.jenvman.2006.02.004.
Tuomisto H.L., Hodge I.D., Riordan P., Macdonald D.W. Does organic farming reduce environmental impacts? - a meta-analysis of European research. J.Environ. Manage. 2012, 112:309-320. 10.1016/j.jenvman.2012.08.018.
Vandenberghe C., Marcoen J.M. Transposition de la Directive Nitrate (CE) en Région wallonne: azote potentiellement lessivable de référence pour les sols cultivés en Région wallonne. Biotechnol. Agron. Soc. Environ. 2004, 8:111-118.
Viavattene C. Exploitation socio-économique de la modélisation souterraine du transfert des nitrates à l'échelle du bassin de la Seine 2006.
Visser A., Dubus I., Broers H.P., Brouyere S., Korcz M., Orban P., Goderniaux P., Batlle-Aguilar J., Surdyk N., Amraoui N., Job H., Pinault J.L., Bierkens M. Comparison of methods for the detection and extrapolation of trends in groundwater quality. J.Environ. Monit. 2009, 2030-2043.
Whitehead J.C., Hoban T.J., Van Houtven G. Willingness to pay and drinking water quality: an examination of the averting behavior approach. 68th Annual Conference of the Southern Economic Association in Baltimore, MD, November 1998 1998.
Zhang Y., Collins A.L., Gooday R.D. Application of the FARMSCOPER tool for assessing agricultural diffuse pollution mitigation methods across the Hampshire avon demonstration test Catchment, UK. Environ. Sci. Policy 2012, 10.1016/j.envsci.2012.08.003.
